Problems and Solutions in the Development of China's New Energy Vehicle Industry

2022-09-23넶Views: 268

The world automotive industry has entered a new era of technological revolution and innovative development, and the automotive industry is accelerating its integration with emerging technologies such as the Internet, big data, cloud computing and artificial intelligence. For China, this is a period of strategic opportunity to transform and upgrade its automotive industry and grow from large to strong.

But at the same time, China inevitably encounters some problems in the course of development. For example, the industrial chain is not yet complete, the cost of key components is high, and charging infrastructure in various regions lags behind. In particular, the unbalanced and inadequate development of the new energy vehicle industry in different regions has become increasingly prominent.

In response to these problems, it is necessary to establish an indicator system to evaluate the development trend of the new energy vehicle industry, and then prescribe the right remedy.

A Powerful Evaluation System

In recent years, China's new energy vehicle industry has developed well, ranking first in the world in both production and sales for three consecutive years. By the end of 2017, the number of new energy vehicles in China had exceeded 1.6 million. More importantly, judging from the industry development trend of the past five years, China's new energy vehicles have entered a stage of rapid growth — in 2017, China's new energy vehicle production and sales reached 794,000 and 777,000 respectively.

 

Trend of China's New Energy Vehicle Production and Sales, 2013–2017

After years of effort, China has indeed formed certain comprehensive comparative advantages in new energy vehicles compared with traditional automotive manufacturing powers such as the United States, Japan and Germany, reflected in technology research and development, industrial development, market cultivation, policy innovation and infrastructure construction. However, for a country whose automotive industry started relatively late, some problems inevitably arise in the course of development.

For example, some provincial and municipal governments and local enterprises blindly follow the trend without scientific assessment and decision-making, and introduce new energy vehicle investment projects on a large scale. However, due to small R&D investment and large plant investment, the new energy vehicle industry shows a trend of "ineffective overcapacity" and "insufficient effective capacity", resulting in a great waste of resources. For another example, compared with the huge industrial scale, the construction of new energy vehicle charging facilities in some provinces and cities still lags behind and can no longer meet market demand.

As one of the important technical routes for new energy vehicles, fuel cell vehicles are even more seriously lagging behind in the construction of supporting hydrogen refueling stations in China, hindering the market-oriented advancement of this industrial direction.

Therefore, we believe it is necessary to establish a powerful evaluation system to carry out a complete and scientific evaluation of the regional development of the new energy vehicle industry. This is the Evaluation Indicator System for Regional Development of the New Energy Vehicle Industry. This evaluation system mainly consists of six indicators: policy layout, industrial scale, technological innovation, industrial chain layout, infrastructure and market performance, and is used to quantitatively analyze the development trend of the new energy vehicle industry in major provinces and cities in China.

Specifically, the total ranking score of regional development of the new energy vehicle industry in each province and city in China in 2017 is composed of the weighted sum of the scores of the six indicators: policy layout, industrial scale, technological innovation, industrial chain layout, infrastructure and market performance. The calculation formula is as follows:

 

So what makes this evaluation system powerful?

At the local level, it can systematically review the current industrial development level and resource endowments of each province and city, so as to leverage strengths and avoid weaknesses, support scientific local decision-making, and avoid the "herding" phenomenon caused by blind layout, which leads to overcapacity and a waste of manpower and financial resources.

At the national level, it can scientifically assess the current status of regional development of China's new energy vehicle industry, help scientifically plan the layout of the upstream and downstream industrial chains of the new energy vehicle industry, prevent regions from rushing into development blindly, and coordinate resources from all parties to guide industrial clustering, creating a favorable environment for the sustained and healthy development of China's new energy vehicles.

What Are Local Policies Focusing On?

Overall, in 2017, provinces and cities not only refined and improved a series of previous related policies in areas such as promotion subsidies and charging facilities, but also greatly expanded the scope of policies to cover enterprise access, technical standards, quality and safety, and other aspects.

Judging from the types of policies issued by the top ten provinces and cities, macro guidance, promotion subsidies and charging facilities remained the key topics of attention in various regions in 2017.

 

Of particular note, in order to implement policy requirements such as the Notice of the Ministry of Industry and Information Technology on Further Improving the Safety Supervision of the Promotion and Application of New Energy Vehicles (MIIT Equipment [2016] No. 377), provinces and cities in 2017 placed particular emphasis on improving quality and efficiency in new energy vehicle policies, and carried out more comprehensive and stricter standardized management of automobile manufacturers and products to ensure safe operation.

Specific measures include: clarifying that manufacturing enterprises are the first responsible party for promoting and applying new energy vehicle products, safety service assurance, power battery recycling and disposal, and reporting of promotion information; establishing safety assurance and emergency rescue mechanisms; and establishing a recall management system for defective automobile products.

In terms of macro guidance, provinces and cities have a more comprehensive and profound understanding of the significance of new energy vehicle development. In addition to basic considerations such as environmental protection and the transformation and upgrading of the automotive industry, they also combine local new energy vehicle development with work such as promoting the energy revolution, alleviating urban congestion and advancing the integration of informatization and industrialization.

In terms of promotion subsidies, major provinces and cities basically follow the requirements and provisions of national documents such as the Notice on Fiscal Support Policies for the Promotion and Application of New Energy Vehicles from 2016 to 2020 (Cai Jian [2015] No. 134) and the Notice on Adjusting the Fiscal Subsidy Policy for the Promotion and Application of New Energy Vehicles (Cai Jian [2016] No. 958), and further clarify and optimize local fiscal subsidy policies for the promotion and application of new energy vehicles, including: adjusting and raising the threshold for the recommended vehicle model catalog and adjusting it dynamically, and setting local fiscal subsidies at no more than 50% of the central fiscal subsidy per vehicle.

In terms of charging facilities, in summary, the policy focus of some provinces and cities in 2017 was mainly on adjusting the charging and battery swap service fee standards.

In terms of investment and construction, in 2017, provinces and cities such as Jiangsu, Tianjin and Guangdong responded to the Notice of the State Council on Several Measures for Expanding Opening-Up and Actively Utilizing Foreign Investment, positioning the future industrial development pattern with the keyword "opening up". By encouraging and guiding foreign investment into the new energy vehicle industry and improving the quality and efficiency of foreign investment utilization, this means that new energy vehicles will, to a certain extent, lose the protection of national economic and trade policies and be released into the international competitive ocean of survival of the fittest. Overall, the further opening of the industry is a reverse-pressure mechanism built to promote quality and efficiency improvement in China's automotive industry and realize the transformation from a major automobile producer to a manufacturing power.

What Risks Deserve Vigilance?

Data released by the China Automobile Dealers Association show that from 2015 to the end of June 2017, more than 200 new energy vehicle projects had been implemented in China, with related investment amounting to more than 1 trillion yuan, and the new energy vehicle capacity plans publicly announced by various automakers exceeded 20 million vehicles.

Influenced by the "dual credit" policy, many automobile manufacturers are now making every effort to lay out new energy technology routes, and the market share of new energy vehicles is expected to further expand in the future. Considering that the total planned capacity of existing localities has far exceeded the national expected target for the industry, there is also much controversy and many opinions in the industry on the question of whether China's new energy vehicle capacity is already excessive.

On the one hand, planned capacity does not equal actual capacity. It is still too early to conclude that "new energy vehicle capacity is already excessive" simply by adding up the planned capacity reported by production entities in various regions. In addition, as an emerging industry, new energy vehicles must go through a process of stimulating the investment enthusiasm of market entities and creating a situation of a hundred flowers blooming in the early stage of development.

On the other hand, localities need to be vigilant against the trend and risk of overcapacity in new energy vehicle planning. Unlike the traditional automobile industry, whose industry and technology have already matured, new energy vehicles are still in a period of rapid technological upgrading and iteration, with great room for future development. Without being able to predict future technology routes, blindly launching a large number of projects entails great risks. Therefore, localities should focus on scientific guidance for investment and capacity planning of new energy vehicle projects and must not be overly aggressive.

Patents Are Truly a Shortcoming That Urgently Needs to Be Addressed

As new energy vehicle technology gradually matures, intellectual property rights of core technologies play a crucial role in increasingly fierce global competition.

At present, patent competition in the international new energy vehicle industry is unusually fierce. Data from the China Automotive Industry Intellectual Property Development Report 2016, jointly released by institutions such as the China Automotive Engineering Research Institute and the Society of Automotive Engineers of China, show that the number of patent applications in the global new energy vehicle field is on the rise overall, and the major patent application countries are mainly traditional automotive powers and emerging automotive market countries.

As of December 31, 2015, the top five countries were the United States, Japan, China, Germany and South Korea, and their applications accounted for 75% of global applications.

But on the whole, compared with new energy vehicle powers, China's new energy vehicle industry still shows a latecomer disadvantage in patents, and it is urgent to identify and fill the shortcomings in industry patents and consolidate the patent foundation for building an automotive power. For example, China's patent applications suffer from problems such as "large but not strong, numerous but not excellent"; the quality of patent applications is not high, the core patent holding rate is low, and most domestic core patent applications are held by foreign enterprises; domestic enterprises' patent applications are relatively scattered and have not yet formed a technological layout advantage, and the possibility of future patent barriers and infringement risks is relatively high.

Core Technologies Have Progressed Significantly

Batteries, electronic controls and motors are the three core technologies of new energy vehicles, and the layout of supporting enterprises is an important indicator of whether the new energy vehicle industry chain is complete. Judging from the number of enterprise layouts in various provinces and cities, China's battery and motor industries are relatively competitive.

In terms of the development of the power battery industry, in recent years China's power battery R&D and manufacturing level has improved substantially, and some domestic power batteries have already gained certain international market competitiveness in terms of energy density, cycle life and safety performance. But at the same time, inconsistent standard processes and insufficient intelligent manufacturing levels are also common problems faced by domestic power battery suppliers.

In terms of the layout of the drive motor industry, after more than a decade of development, China's automotive drive motor technology has made considerable progress, and drive motor system products meeting the needs of various new energy vehicles have been independently developed, forming mass production capacity.

Hydrogen Refueling Station Layout Lags Behind

Data released by the China Electric Vehicle Charging Infrastructure Promotion Alliance show that as of the end of 2017, member units of the alliance had cumulatively reported 213,903 public charging piles. In 2017, 72,649 new public charging piles were added, a growth rate of 51%.

Compared with the construction of charging facilities, which has attracted much attention from various regions, the layout of hydrogen refueling stations in China lags behind. Before 2015, the few hydrogen refueling stations built and operated in China were basically supporting facilities for fuel cell vehicle demonstration projects in major events (such as the Olympic Games, the World Expo and the Universiade), and they lost the impetus for continued operation after the demonstration projects ended. After 2015, as the domestic fuel cell vehicle industry heated up, the number of hydrogen refueling stations built and planned has increased. Although many cities across the country are also planning to build hydrogen refueling stations, they have not yet formed a scale overall.

 

Statistics on the Number of Hydrogen Refueling Stations in Provinces and Cities Across China

At present, the common difficulty faced by various regions in the planning and construction of hydrogen refueling stations is the lack of standardized approval procedures and clear competent approval departments.

On the one hand, planning departments in many provinces and cities treat hydrogen refueling stations, a new thing, the same as fully marketized gasoline or gas stations, and copy national standards and specifications for gasoline and gas stations in terms of site selection and land use nature. This "one-size-fits-all" approach is one of the main reasons for the "hard to find a site" problem in the planning and construction of hydrogen refueling stations.

On the other hand, due to different regulatory and approval departments and complicated approval procedures, approval efficiency is relatively low. Enterprises building hydrogen refueling stations in various provinces and cities usually have to spend a lot of manpower, material resources and time costs on approval procedures.

Public Interest in New Energy Vehicles Continues to Rise

We captured public comments on new energy vehicle-related news in 2017. A total of 300,699 valid analysis samples were obtained through model sampling, including 26,510 positive comments and 18,272 negative comments; neutral comments accounted for more than 85%, indicating that the public holding a neutral, wait-and-see attitude toward new energy vehicles still accounts for an absolute majority.

 

Through analysis of the data content, it can be seen that the new energy vehicle topics of greater public interest in 2017 included: new energy vehicle brands, power types, prices, subsidy policies, etc.

 

It is worth noting that the Chinese public is still highly sensitive to the price of new energy vehicles; however, in the segmented field of consumer experience, the topic of "regretting buying a new energy vehicle" attracted widespread public attention at certain times in 2017, which shows that whether performance is excellent and complete has gradually become an important reference for Chinese people when purchasing new energy vehicles.

In addition, by sorting out and analyzing the annual online search index for new energy vehicles and combining it with content analysis, the report derived the trend of public interest in new energy vehicles in China in 2017. It can be seen that the search heat for new energy vehicles across the Internet reached relatively high peaks in April, September, November and December.

Through content analysis, the main events highly correlated with the 2017 peak of public attention are shown in the following figure:

 

The government has successively issued a series of programmatic documents focusing on key directions such as energy-saving and new energy vehicles and intelligent connected vehicles, providing a guide to action for promoting the automotive industry from large to strong.